  ::  | Welcome to our newest Canuck, ZRocker. | |
| Canucks active in this forum: | ||
| Canucks active in this thread: Visiting Canuck | ||
|
17 people online in the last 60 minutes - 0 Canucks, 0 Canucks In Hiding and 17 Visiting Canucks. (Most ever was 233 at 09:22:13 Fri Sep 21 2007) |
| Pages: [ 1 2 ] |
 |  |  |  |
  |
Wabes 
|
Is anyone mad at Jimmy for giving the Kashmir track to Puffy besides me?
|
LedZeppelinHarmony  I'm Hiding  1000302 posts    Mood Now: 
|
Well, I would be lying if I said I was happy with him for doing that, but I can't really be mad at Jimmy for what he does with his music! I mean, it's his music and his life and he doesn't really need his fans' approval! I mean, don't get me wrong! I wish he didn't do it! But still, it's not really our place to make any judgments on it! Led Zeppelin rules!
|
|
Frodo
|
I think Pagey is awesome and has a right to do what he did, but Puffy sucks! I thik pagey should stay with plant and jonsey, and thats all. Everyone else he works with destroys his masterpieces.
|
retro chica  I'm Asleep  5872 posts   Mood Now: 
|
It's his music; he can do whatever he wants with it.
|
Canada rules!
Kathy Garfunkel  I'm Asleep 780 posts   Mood Now: 
|
i don't really like the puff daddy/p diddy version, but it's jimmy's call.
 |
|
Emily Garfunkel I'm Asleep 6565 posts  Mood Now: 
|
Okay, I'm kinda torn on this one.
 One one hand, I do realize that it's Jimmy's music and he doesn't need his fans' approval to do whatever he chooses with his music.  But on the other hand, I can definately understand being upset over seeing Kashmir get buchered into a rap tune.  There's absolutely no telling how I would feel if Paul Simon or Art Garfunkel gave my absolute favourite Simon & Garfunkel song, Bridge Over Troubled Water, over to a rap artist to butcher. :whip: Anyway, I guess being the rational person that I try to be, I can actually view this from both perspectives. 
|
|
led_zep_head I'm Asleep 1610 posts  Mood Now: 
|
I don't really like the song with Puff Daddy, but it really doesn't pay to get mad about it. What's done is done and getting mad about it won't change or undo anything.
|
|
Led Zeppelin Lurk I'm Asleep posts  Mood Now:
|
i'm probably in the minority here when i say i actually do like the puff daddy song, come with me.
|
|
moonshine I'm Asleep 56 posts    Mood Now: 
|
What do you think about the way this song was integrated into the soundtrack for the movie "Godzilla", when it was broken down into the Zepplin playing the music, and Puff Daddy doing a rap type lyric to it? Inquiring minds want to know??
|
|
Cecelia_Garfunkel I'm Asleep 3421 posts  Mood Now: 
|
I didn't like it at all, but it is his music. 
|
|
Peggy_Garfunkel I'm Asleep 4510 posts  Mood Now: 
|
I don't really like rap, but I do have to admit that I kinda do like that song.
|
siblygirl  I'm Asleep 1000147 posts  Mood Now: 
|
Never let it be said that rapper/producer Puff Daddy (a.k.a. Bad Boy Records honcho Sean "Puffy" Combs) limits himself to the hip-hop world. To follow up his collaboration with Foo Fighters leader Dave Grohl and pop-rockers Perfect on the "It's All About the Benjamins" remix, Puffy is teaming with former Led Zeppelin guitarist Jimmy Page for a remix of that band's legendary track "Kashmir" for the upcoming "Godzilla" soundtrack.
|
|
Led_Zeppelin_Lurk I'm Asleep posts Mood Now:
|
i know many were upset with jimmy for doing that.
|
AprilWineChick  I'm Asleep 7847 posts  Mood Now: 
|
Okay, here are my views on this: we, as the fans, might have certain preferences as to what our favourite artists might choose to do with their music - but, ultimately, it's up to the artists themselves to decide what to do with their music. And we, as the fans, really have no business to be critisising what our favourite artists might choose to do with their music. As somebody had already indicated in this thread, it is *their* music and *they* can do whatever they want with their music. Would I be happy if Myles Goodwyn of April Wine gave one of their songs for a rapper to do? Not especially, but I wouldn't get mad at him about it. I would realize that that it's *his* music and whatever he does with *his* music is his choice and his choice alone - and he does *not* need his fans' approval to do whatever he wants with his music. I'm not saying that we have to agree with every decision that our favourite artists makes - but I do feel that it really is not our place to be telling them what to do with their music. And that's that.
|
|
Peggy_Garfunkel I'm Asleep 4510 posts Mood Now:
|
Right on, AprilWineChick!
|
|
pyxi_styx I'm Asleep 3982 posts   Mood Now: 
|
It's up to Jimmy what he wants to do with his music - it really is not up to us to be deciding what he should do with his music.
 Peace out. 
|
|
led_zep_head I'm Asleep 1610 posts Mood Now:
|
Exactly, what Jimmy does with his music is strictly his business. We don't have to like it - but we do have to respect that the discisions he makes are totally his.
|
|
Oowatanite I'm Asleep 2965 posts  
|
it really is not our place to tell the led zeppelin members what they should do with their music.
|
|
Emily_Garfunkel I'm Asleep 6565 posts Mood Now:
|
I agree, Oowatanite.
|
| Pages: [ 1 2 ] |
| | | |
|
|
Total Canucks: 122, Newest Canuck: ZRocker. | Register :: :: In Power The time is now 04:58:23 Mon May 20 2013 |
© 2001-2007 BbBoy.net